Ross is a strong foe of drunk driving who began studying the problem long before the existence of MADD. He has identified research-based evidence of which policies are most effective in reducing drunk driving.
This, in an effort to exaggerate the extent of the problem. This is over twice the legal limit of 0. Mann, in turn, had extracted those numbers from two separate studies whose data was culled from Sweden and Australia.
As well as the limitations inherent to the Australian study. For starters, the Aussie study examined the effectiveness of spot checks, not lower BAC on fatal traffic collisions. Also, that research was initiated at a time when liquid lunches were far more common. The MADD proposal would make it illegal for a small woman to drive after consuming a single drink. Also, it would divert police resources away from high-risk, high BAC, hard-core drivers. Yet more money » Mothers Against Drunk Driving is always hungry for more money.
It has enormous assets. Yet it pays huge fees to raise tens of millions of dollars per year. It would appear that raising money has become an end in itself at the MADD bureaucracy. It has with many employees, high salaries, expensive fringe benefits, and huge retirement funds.
However, an investigative report by the Toronto-Star reveals a very different story. That agency regulates charities. So only 19 per cent of donations go for its programs and services! Why the enormous discrepancy? Because MADD counts payments to professional fundraisers as charitable work.
It claims they educate potential donors as they make their pitch. However, the AIP and similar groups have long insisted that such a practice is deceptive. He insists that its practice of counting payments to professional fundraisers as charitable work is acceptable. However, the Charities Directorate specifically disputes his contention and says the practice is definitely prohibited. It wrote to the MADD corporation. However, the Charities Directorate says this method is not approved.
It emphasizes that charities must carefully distinguish their good works from their fundraising campaigns. MADD chapters across the country demanded in a conference call that Murie order an outside independent audit. However, he refused and only agreed to an internal self-review of its finances. She said the group found the MADD leader to be uncooperative.
Veteran volunteers oppose deceitful fundraising. That happened shortly after a newspaper story exposing highly questionable fundraising practices quoted him. He also feels a sense of betrayal. MADD has never liked any questions by anyone about its finances. Earlier, MADD pushed gambling events to follow high school proms!
MADD strongly opposes letting parents or priests serve alcohol to adults under the age of Yet it promotes gambling among young adults. However, 18 to 21 year old adults are about three times more likely to have problems with gambling.
Rachel Volberg. Perhaps MADD should re-think its promotion of gambling, even though it generates income for the corporation. One noteworthy case was the battle over two California ballot initiatives. However, MADD aligned itself with a group of out-of-state insurance companies. MADD defended its position. It said drunk drivers, if convicted only of lesser charges, could sue insurance companies under the proposed law. However, MADD never budged from its contradictory position.
The organizations motive? Greed, plain and simple. GM is a good example. Speeding is a factor in about 31 percent of all fatal crashes. Yet General Motors very aggressively promotes speeding as a pleasurable activity to sell its cars. What does MADD say about speeding? They have long found that many vehicle models have very poor safety records. Improving such models might save thousands of deaths each year. And laws requiring auto makers to meet higher safety standards on all vehicles might save thousands more.
Does MADD let its desire for multi-million dollar contributions influence its position on safety issues? They did so along with free airtime. MADD uncharacteristically but very aggressively promotes the use of seatbelts. Aligning with MADD gives your company added credibility and increased power by:. Several supermarket chains have been substantial contributors of money to the chapter. However, MADD virtually always opposes any law that increases the availability of alcohol to the public.
Therefore, it gives awards to officers who make progigeous numbers of such arrests. Also, MADD determines exactly the level of donation to itself. They are a very profitable business for MADD. However, there is little evidence that they are effective at all in reducing drunk driving. The privilege was originally provided over years. It was a to protect members of Congress from politically-motivated arrests. Doing so would prevent then from voting. The privilege of immunity serves no useful purpose today.
MADD could pressures to stop its outrageous misuse. Unfortunately, MADD insists on being silent on the issue. It receives massive taxpayer funding through Congress. And the same parent, according to students, sponsored at least three such teen parties with alcohol.
This is exactly the sort of thing that outrages MADD. Police have charged the parent with illegally allowing minors to drink alcohol. So MADD looks the other way rather than offend the hand that feeds it. Cynics might say that MADD has its priorities.
This was in an effort to promote its legislative agenda. Apparently, the only victims who count are those of drunk drivers. MADD trivializes other crashes and their victims. MADD has the right to believe as it wishes. But it should learn to be less blatantly self-promoting. But alcohol-related only means that officers think that anyone connected with the crash has been drinking.
This is a very important distinction. Confusing people by equating the two is not in the public interest. MADD sometimes expresses hostility toward those who defend the rights of suspects. It assumes suspects to be guilty. Everybody in MADD knows about him.
One MADD leader goes even further. However, their goal is to abstain completely from alcohol for the rest of their lives. Is this just vengeful punishment because some alcoholics drive drunk and have caused tragedy to MADD members? But also to anyone who disagrees with the group. Mothers Against Drunk Driving has a long tradition of hostility toward the rights of the accused. It assumes them to be guilty unless they can prove their innocence. MADD has a long history of doing this. Yet it admits that it has never verbally defended the rights or presumption of innocence of an accused defendant.
The ads simply announce the availability of legal counsel for those suspected of drunk driving. The ad that outrages MADD simply states the following. MADD officials insist that announcing the availability of legal counsel sends the wrong message. Lawyers point out that every Canadian has a right to legal counsel. They stress that everyone needs to understand this fact because impaired driving is such a serious crime with serious consequences.
To the contrary, the ad may serve to remind people that drunk driving is a very serious crime. In addition, it requires the services and expenses of a lawyer. However, society must ask if this is a fair trade. Apparently MADD thinks it is. The burden of proof is correctly on the state. MADD leaders should take re-take civics at their local middle schools. She struck a pedestrian and failed to seek medical help for him. The defendant claimed the charge should not be murder. A MADD official was very angry at the defense.
Intoxication is never an acceptable defense for any action. But to deny a citizen the right to a trial because of that defense is, itself, indefensible. That makes sense. Such a person would be completely innocent. However, MADD has strongly criticized the ruling. And they must do so before giving field sobriety tests. Lawmakers passed the law to prevent courts from overturning cases. Officers can still require a blood test of drivers if probable cause exists.
Probable cause is anything that suggests a person may have consumed any alcohol. For example, such things as slurred speech or the odor of alcohol. Nevertheless, MADD is angry. Yet the Constitution guarantees them.
Among other things, the MADD chapter had interfered in ongoing criminal investigations, including irresponsible vigilantism. The MADD chapter accused a store of selling beer to a teenager. That teen later had an auto crash killing two people. Of course, there was no apology by MADD. The MADD chapter defends its unfounded attacks and other illegal actions.
Mothers Against Drunk Driving was originally a public service group to reduce drunk driving deaths. However, it has largely become an anti-alcohol bureaucracy. And it largely focuses on raising ever more money for itself. MADD in Action mag. Lightner, C. From Grief to Anger. In: Frantzich, S. Citizen Democracy. Lanham, MD: Rowman, MADD as hell and not going to take it anymore.
Broadcast , April, , , Downing, T. Enterprise , Sept 4, College Drinking and Junk Science. MADD enters 25th year with change on its mind. USA Today , Sept 29, Donovan, K. Toronto-Star , Dec 9, Mohl, B. Boston Globe, Oct 5, Donnelly, F. Detroit News , Aug 16, Meet the people behind the statistics.
Voices of Victims: Ryan Nealon I remember my mother in fragments. I know that her name was Terri and that she was 44 when I was born. I know that we lived in a one-bedroom apartment in San Diego, just the two of us and our cat. It was a sunny day near Baton Rouge, Louisiana, plenty warm for the kids to eat ice cream outside and for Khaiden to get It had sustained me through the excruciating pain and panic of an ambulance ride.
It had sustained me as a team of doctors and nurses moved my broken body from one machine and test to another, and through the hours-long wait for my family. Here you will find ways to donate, volunteer, take action and get involved directly with that chapter. MADD provides free supportive services to the victims and survivors of drunk and drugged driving, as well as underage drinking. The Problem. The Solution. Get Help.
Get Involved. About MADD. Shop MADD. Victim Impact Panels. Local Offices.
0コメント